Skip navigation

Category Archives: Power

Posts about power

After finally securing my Domestic Violence victim interview – with a lady from Walsall named Zoe – I have revised the questions that I am going to ask in the interview. After having email liasons with her i’ve gained a brief outline of her situation from during the abuse and her life now so I have re-written the interview accordingly.

I have emailed her a copy of the questions and she is happy with them so hopefully during the recording tomorrow it makes for an interesting interview.

Tell me about your relationship at the beginning.

Did you see any early signs of abuse, whether verbal or violent?

When and how did things begin to change?

When did he resort to violence?

Did this just happen when he was drunk, or when sober also?

Who initiated the arguments, was there always substance behind them or did they seem to come out of nowhere?

Why didn’t you leave him straight away?

What was going through your mind at this stage? Did you notice any changes in your own personality?

Was there anyone you confiding in during this abuse?

At what point did you realise you’ve had enough and needed to get help?

Who or where did you contact first to get help?

What support were you given?

What punishment did he receive?

Time has passed now and you are remarried. Please explain what support you are still receiving and from whom.

What do you think the biggest myth is about domestic violence?


Do you think there is anything that could be done from an early age, during education for example, to stop domestic abuse before it’s happens?


What advice would you give for those in the situation that you were in, or those who think a friend or relative is being abused?

There are no new ideas in television, everything has been done before. Your task is to find a different way of doing it, to find a new angle, to give it a new treatment.

Researching for Television and Radio (Media Skills) by Adele Emm

The subject  I am looking into may not be the most original… but if I can look at it from another direction: think outside the box then hopefully I can gain interest in my piece and gain a good mark.

For my first artifact in term 1, I designed a website in which I would showcase my Domestic Violence documentary. It was very basic in design, and as I have become aware during my research – extremely inappropriate for my target audience and unsuitable to be used in my final major project.

Initial website

Initial website

Obviously it is a very basic initial idea but it must be improved greatly and most likely completely redesigned.

I will look at other websites on the subject of domestic violence and see how they look and use this as an influence of my redesigned website, as well as making sure all the content is relevent and appropriate for my project.

I’ve found a few domestic violence adverts on youtube:

One:

This clip shows the different ways that domestic violence could take place, not just violence. However, all the cases seem to be aimed against women – no women causing it to men – it makes out the problem is very one dimensional and this is simply not the case. Maybe it would be more appropriate to reverse some of the roles in a few of the scenes.

Two:

This advert I specifically powerful as it gives a different side to the information the audience are receiving. It shows what happens to the person that has commited the crime: in this case, the man has beaten the woman and it has led to him losing his wife and children – it tries to stop this happening before it begins and to warn the man or woman if they start commiting this crime then they may lose everything.

Three:

This one again goes down a different route. Aimed at those who might be aware that domestic violence is happening – and pleading for them to phone the authorities instead of turning a blind eye.

Unfortunately I could not find any videos aimed at helping male victims. I shall keep looking but it is interesting to note, there are many people wanting to help the women but who listens to the men?

While having a browse around the internet, I found this article about an MFI advert being banned as it trivialised domestic violence.

The bathroom ad slap that landed MFI in hot water for ‘trivialising’ domestic violence

A television advert that ‘trivialised’ domestic violence has been banned after a flood of complaints from viewers.

The commercial for MFI shows a couple rowing after the man leaves a toilet seat up.

The woman yells, “You’ve done it again, haven’t you?” before slapping him twice.

[...]

Those who complained – including a victim of domestic violence – described the adverts variously as ‘ offensive, shocking and disturbing’.

The ASA said: “Several found the ads distressing and particularly offensive because they believed they trivialised the issues of child and domestic abuse.”

“The woman’s action of slapping her husband twice as punishment for leaving the toilet seat up gave the impression that aggression and violence enabled people in everyday life to get their own way.

“The scene of domestic violence was likely to cause serious or widespread offence and could be seen to condone intimidation, domestic violence and aggression as an acceptable way to resolve issues.”

Granted, this article was from The Daily Mail but it actually raises a good few points and talks some sense.

Now, is this political correctness gone mad or are they genuinely making light of a horrible crime? Surely, if it was the other way around and a man was slapping/hitting a woman for making a silly little mistake – everybody would be up in arms over what they are seeing – so what’s the difference in a woman slapping a man?

I think the dometic violence companies were correct to make this a big deal as it really shows that people aren’t taking domestic violence towards men seriously and adverts like this would only go on to trivialise it.

Probably the most famous case of domestic violence on television of the past few years is the situation on the BBC One soap opera Eastenders.

The character Little Mo was put through a terrible ordeal from her husband Trevor. A brief overview of their story.

The first love of Little Mo’s life was Trevor Morgan. She was a victim of his domestic violence and put up with his severe mood swings. She was extremely frightened of him, as he would beat her for minor things. He mentally manipulated her until her mind was so fragile that she just couldn’t bring herself to leave him, and he would always turn on the charm after hitting her, and she was convinced that she loved him and he felt the same way.

Trevor eventually made her become more isolated from her family who strongly depised Trevor and raped her on the bathroom floor when she told him she was going to her sister, Lynne’s, wedding. On Christmas Day, Trevor shoved Mo’s face in her Christmas dinner and made her eat it off the floor, a scene which attracted huge controversy and complaints from viewers.

On New Year’s Eve, timid ‘doormat’ Little Mo broke out of her shell and attacked Trevor, bashing him repeatedly around the head with an iron when he prepared to attack her. She initially thought he’d died and when she and her sisters returned home, he had gone, with only blood on the door handle as a sign. Mo was prosecuted and imprisoned for attempted murder, released on appeal. Trevor terrorised Mo after she managed to move on and planned to divorce him, but he took her hostage in her house, which accidentally set on fire. Fireman Tom Banks saved Mo, and when he went back in to get Trevor, they were both burned alive.

EastEnders was criticised for being too violent during the domestic violence scenes between this couple, as EastEnders is shown pre-watershed, there were worries that some scenes in this storyline were too graphic for its audience. However Eastenders argued that these scenes just showed the harsh truths that some people are put through. Complaints against the scene where Little Mo’s face was pushed in gravy on Christmas Day were upheld by the Broadcasting Standards Council. However, a helpline after this episode attracted over 2000 calls – showing what a fantastic help these scenes were for the domestic violence cause.

Erin Pizzey, an  international women’s rights figurehead for having started one of the first Women’s Refuges, said that EastEnders had done more to raise the issue of violence against women in one story than she had done in twenty-five years.

A family member of mine has been suffering in silence over domestic violence over the past 2 years. This year, she finally got help and got away from her husband’s control.

Many people within the Media Industry say the best ideas come from speaking to people about real life situations and hearing my family member’s story and side of the situation, I was inspired to look into domestic violence and how it effects the victims, families and even those committing the violence.

HERE ARE SOME FACTS ABOUT DOMESTIC VIOLENCE

Common myths

There are lots of myths and stereotypes about domestic violence. The facts are very different…

  • She could just leave
  • It mainly happens to poor women on council estates
  • It’s alcohol that causes men to be violent
  • Abused women must have done something to deserve it
  • Certain women attract violent men
  • Abusers were abused themselves
  • Violent men can’t change
  • Domestic violence is quite rare.
  • If children don’t see the violence, they won’t be affected
  • You shouldn’t get involved in other people’s rowsDo violent song lyrics, computer games or films glorify domestic violence?

The Basics

Domestic violence happens in all sections of society, it includes physical, emotional, sexual, financial and other abuse. Its victims are very vulnerable. Those who experience domestic violence are often isolated from friends, family and others sources of help. Domestic violence is often considered a ‘private’ crime; it occurs ‘behind closed doors’ and the victims find it hard to talk about or even to admit that it is happening.

There is no single, simple answer to the problem. Change involves tackling public attitudes, making violence unacceptable and ensuring that the criminal justice system is more sensitive to victims’ needs.

Inside Information

How many people are affected by domestic violence?

The police in the UK receive, on average, one call a minute from someone asking for help in a domestic violence incident. Yet this figure — over 500,000 incidents a year — is probably only a third of the domestic violence that actually happens. In four out of every five incidents the victims are women, and more than half of victims of domestic violence are victimised more than once. No other type of crime has a repeat victimisation rate this high.

How does domestic violence affect children?

Children often witness domestic violence. Indeed, there seems to be a strong link between people who abuse children and people who abuse partners or ex-partners. Domestic violence often increases when women marry, become pregnant and have children. In almost a third of relationships where domestic violence happens it starts during pregnancy.

Are men ever victims of domestic violence?

Domestic violence does affect men, but it can be very hard for them to talk about. Just under 1 in 5 victims of domestic violence in the British Crime Survey 2001/2002 were men. Yet a Scottish Crime Survey found that a majority of men who said they were victims of domestic violence were also perpetrators. Men are less likely to be repeat victims than women and are less likely to be seriously injured. However, serious domestic violence against men is thought to be very under-reported because of social stigmas.

What does the criminal justice system do?

The criminal justice system has had difficulties in dealing with domestic violence.  Victims are often reluctant to give evidence against their partners either because they are too frightened, or because there has been a reconciliation and they want to believe it will not happen again.  Over the last few years there have been major improvements.  Police in many areas have specialist staff who are able to work with people suffering domestic violence, offering them advice and information about where they can go to be safe and logging incidents even when no further action is taken so that a proper picture is built up of the extent of the problem.

Why don’t victims just leave?

Many victims do leave. But it isn’t as easy as it sounds. Victims may be threatened if they leave. Women leaving violent relationships often report being frightened that their abuser will find them and feel that they are constantly looking over their shoulder. Staying in the violent relationship, and coping with it, may seem a less terrifying option.  There is also the problem of finding somewhere to go. According to government figures, women and children fleeing violence in the home account for 16% of those on local authorities’ homeless lists and 40% of all homeless women said that domestic violence was a factor in them becoming homeless.

Changing Attitudes

Part of the problem lies in the fact that attitudes about violence against women are so deeply ingrained. One major research study found that 1 in 2 boys and 1 in 3 girls find it acceptable to hit a woman in certain circumstances (e.g. if they nag).

Over half the young people knew someone who had been hit by their male partner and half knew someone who had been sexually assaulted.

Did you know?

In 2002 there were about 635,000 incidents of domestic violence in England and Wales. Of all reported violent assaults, domestic violence makes up about a fifth.

In 2001 42% of all female murder victims were killed by current or former partners, compared with only 4% of male homicide victims. This equates to 102 women; an average of 2 women each week.

1 in 4 women in Europe experience domestic violence over their lifetimes and between 6-10% of women suffer domestic violence in any given year.

Brief outline of the idea.

- Documentary, with interviews, facts and reconstructions of the violence.
- Informs the viewers and reaches out to those in violent relationships to talk to people, get help.
- Interviews with those convicted of domestic violence, how they felt when they were commiting it, why they did it, what happened in the end, what punishment they received and what help they had to try and overcome the urge to commit these offences.

http://www.rbwmdvf.org.uk/ – royal borough of windsor

http://www.womensaid.org.uk/

Out on my own, feel much more comfortable in a group.

Power: Website – domestic violence.

WEBSITE LINK

Influenced by:

  • Own family members’ experiences
  • EastEnders: Little Mo/Trevor

Things that went wrong:

  • planned to do audio interview, she dropped out

Things that went well:

  • website – very informative, though is it adding anything new? Too much to take on – market full already.

Spectacle: Photography – 5-a-side football.

Influences:

  • Zidane, 21st portrait
  • Match of the Day – my love for football – aims for the future

Things that went wrong:

  • games being cancelled
  • forced to go indoors
  • not very good at photography!

Memory: Audio piece – footballing memories

Influences:

  • Channel 4 idents
  • Laws of the Playground
  • Childhood memories

Problems:

  • Changed my idea halfway through to football
  • Operation

Things that went well:

  • sound effects really added to the atmosphere
  • Few nice quirky stories

What i’d change

  • more varied interviewees would of added to the piece.


What i’ve learnt:

Better planning, anticipation needed, always have a plan B. Sometimes things happen that are out of your control.

Onto the future… work with more depth.. and a cause?

Freedom Train // Ewa

Ian Wright’s fat kids, Jamie Oliver, Sir Trevor Brooking’s views on the future of football, campaigns to get more children to exercise

Build on my memory artefact. A merger of the two themes, memories of childhood football along with footage of youth football along with ways to get into football and staying healthy.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.